Eric Vilmer
10/12/20
Professor Simpson
The Way of the Human Being
This essay is probably my favorite essay we have read this semester and also the
hardest. The destruction of alaskan native culture and all native culture for that matter is
always a difficult topic for me to discuss. “The Way of the Human Being” was written by
Harold Napoleon, who is a Yup’ik native from Hooper Bay, Alaska. He starts his essay off
on how many people believe native alcohol addiction is due to not being exposed to it until
way later than other cultures but his essay gets way deeper. He also points out that he does
not hold a doctorate or masters degree but adds that he is from a world that no longer exists,
a world that was taken from him. Napoleon believes that alcohol abuse among natives is not
physical among native people but spiritual. He feels that many, if not all natives feel as if
they have no voice as white people came to their lands and lied to them and forced them to
relearn everything they believed. The Yup’ik children could not practice their own native
religion and were forced to convert to Christianity. Many native people quit speaking
because of how hurt they were, perhaps even shocked by their entire world being taken
away from them. Napoleon points out that many natives exhibited what is now called PTSD
due to the radical lifestyle changes they had to make by force because another culture that
was not from their believed they were savages and were going to hell. The solution to the
problem of alcohol abuse according to Napoleon is to give alaskan natives control of their
land and resources. Many natives in the lower 48 have regained control over lands and they
can manage the resources without government interference. In Alaska, native people are not
allowed to control their resources. Outside companies are legally allowed to extract
resources on native land. Napoleon suggests a similar approach to the lower 48 states where
native people regain full control over their lands as a way to end their depression and get
over their alcohol addiction.
Eric, you point to an important contradiction at the end of your post: the differentiated control of land between Native Alaskans and multinational corporations. It would be valuable to bring in some examples of what you have in mind here or from the other readings. Does Napoleon's essay connect to other arguments we have encountered in our readings?
ReplyDelete